For: Ibn Abbaas, Ibrahim An-Nakh`i and Judge Abdul-Jabbaar Al-Humazhaani (about 5:107 only, according to Aş-Şa`di), Al-Hasan, Az-Zuhri (in one report), Ikrima, Zayd ibn Aslam (according to Ibn Al-Jawzi said Az-Zalmi and confirmed by Shu`la), Maalik, Ash-Shaafi`i, Abu-Haneefa, Makki (according to Shu`la), Ibn Hazm Al-Andalusi, Ibn Salaama (who considers this claim three separate abrogation cases), Abu-Ali (Al-Jabaa'i?) (according to Aş-Şa`di), As-Suyooti.
Against: The majority, according to Al-Qaasim ibn Salaam, Ibn Abbaas (in another report and confirmed by Shu`la), `Aa'isha (according to Makki and Al-Khazraji), Ibn Mas`ood (implied by his allowance of People of the Book as witnesses to a Muslim will), Abdullah ibn Qays (implied by An-Nahhaas), Abu-Moosa Al-Ash`ari, Sa`eed ibn Al-Musayyib, Sa`eed Ibn Jabeer, Ibn Seereen, Qataada, Ash-Sha`bi, Sufyaa ibn `Uayana Ath-Thawri, Mujaahid, Judge Shurayh ibn Al-Haarith, An-Nakh`i, Al-Awzaa`i, Al-Hasan, Ibn Shihaab Az-Zuhri (in another report and confirmed by Shu`la), As-Suddi (according to Shu`la), `Ubayda ibn Hameed At-Taymi, Al-Qaasim ibn Salaam, Khumara ibn Habeeb and `Atiyya ibn Qays, `Amr ibn Shurahbeel Al-Hamadaani aka Abu-Maysara, Yahya ibn Mu`ammar (according to Dr. Al-Husayni), Yahya ibn Ya`mur (according to Shu`la. Maybe he is the same as ibn Mu`ammar?), Ahmad Ibn Hanbal, At-Tabari, Ibn Al-Jawzi, Ar-Raazi (according to Az-Zalmi), Ibn Taymiya, An-Nahhaas, Makki, Al-Asfahaani, Ibn Katheer (according to Dr. Zayd), Ash-Shawkaani (in his book فتح القدير, volume 2, page 86), Yahya ibn Al-Husayn aka Al-Haadi and Abdullah ibn Al-Husayn (according to Aş-Şa`di), Shah Waliullah Dehlvi, Az-Zurqaani, Ar-Raazi, Muhammad Al-Khudhari (Bek), Al-Jabri, Ali Hasan Al-Areedh, Dr. Mustafa Zayd, M. M. Nada, Dr. Az-Zalmi, Dr. Muhammad Saalih Ali Mustafa, Dr. N.A. Tantaawi, Ihab Hasan Abduh, Jamaal `Ataaya.
_________________ A candle loses nothing by lighting another candle.
|