In this topic, I want to list, for reference, the abrogation claims that do have merit, as well as those that really do not. This topic will be linked to from the Bookmarks announcement. Claims with an asterisk after them are claims approved by a large number of scholars. Claims with a Dollar sign after them are claims about money Claims with an equals sign after them are claims about women, and those with an X after them are claims about non-Muslims.
With merit: 3:85/2:62,5:69X 5:5/2:173,16:115 4:11-12/2:180*$ Hadeeth/2:180*$ 2:187/2:183*= 2:286/2:284* 64:16/3:102 24:2/4:15-16= 9:1/4:92X 5:5/6:121 5:3/6:145 8:66/8:65X 58:13/58:12$ 73:20-73:1-4
With some merit: 4:48/2:81 9:29/2:109X 2:144/2:115 5:45/2:178* 2:185/2:184* 9:60/2:215$ 5:90/2:219* 5:5/2:221*= Sunna/2:222= 2:234/2:240*$= 65:4/2:240* 5:90/4:43* 4:129/4:3= 4:48/4:18 8:75/4:33$ 5:90/4:43 5:91/4:43 4:48/4:93 9:60/6:141$ 5:3,Hadeeth/6:145 8:41/8:1$ 47:35/8:61X 8:75,33:6/8:72 Hadeeth/19:26 8:41/59:7$ 5:5,9:1/60:10=$
Without merit: Declarative: 9:60/2:3$ Sunna/3:41 9:29/3:111X 17:18/3:145 8:34/8:33 9:99/9:97-98 17:18/11:15 4:48/13:6 5:90/16:67 Hadeeth/3:41 19:72/19:71 Hadeeth/21:78-79$ 21:101-103/21:98-100 4:48,4:93/25:68-70 37:107/37:102 Sunna,narration/38:33 40:7/42:5 17:18/42:20 9:29/59:3X
Exception: 2:160/2:159 Hadeeth/2:173 2:191/2:190X 4:4,4:20/2:229$ 3:89/3:86-88 4:18/4:17 4:146/4:145 5:5/5:3X 6:121/5:5X 5:34/5:33 Hadeeth/5:38$ 5:96/5:95 9:91,9:122,48:17/9:39,9:41X 9:84/9:103 9:122/9:120X 4:48/16:106 19:60/19:59 5:3/22:30 24:5/24:4= 24:60/24:31= 25:70/25:68-69 26:227/26:224 Hadeeth/65:6=$ 87:7/87:6 103:3/103:2
Self-abrogation: 2:191/2:191X 2:196/2:196 2:229/2:229= 2:233/2:233$= 2:235/2:235= 2:282/2:282$ 3:97/3:97 4:19/4:19$= 4:22/4:22= 4:23/4:23= 4:25/4:25= 4:29/4:29$ 5:105/5:105 16:106/16:106 24:31/24:31= 40:77/40:77 42:40/42:40
Elaboration: 2:286,9:122/2:216X 33:49,65:4/2:228= 2:237/2:236*$= 2:283/2:282$ 4:11/4:7$= Sunna/4:11-12$ 2:228/4:24= 24:61/4:29$ 9:91/4:71X 5:49/5:42X 8:58/9:2X 24:62/9:43-45X 5:89/16:91 9:113/17:24 76:30,81:29/18:29 2:286,64:16/22:78 24:6/24:4= 24:7,9/24:6= 24:29/24:27 24:59/24:58 9:29/29:46$X 73:3/73:1-2 73:4/73:3
Partial abrogation: 17:33/2:178 9:17/5:2
No conflict: 9:36/2:217*X 9:103,9:60/2:219$ 2:229-230/2:228 65:1/2:229 2:185/2:286 16:125/3:20X 2:220/4:2$ 4:10,29/4:6$ 4:11/4:8*$ 2:220/4:10$ 9:80/4:64 9:1-11/4:90,60:8X 2:191/4:91X Sunna/4:101 65:2/5:106-108 48:2/6:15 4:140/6:68-69 2:220/6:152$ 9:60/7:199$ 8:66/8:15-16X 8:39-40/8:38X 47:4/8:67X 9:29/9:5X 47:4/9:5X 9:60,9:103/9:34$ 63:6,9:84/9:80 9:36/9:123X 16:110/16:106 2:220/17:34$ 3:77/14:34 83:1/17:35 7:205,15:94/17:110 87:6/20:114 39:3/22:39X 87:6/22:52 4:25/24:2= 24:32:24:3= 24:7/24:4= 24:3/24:32= 4:29/24:61 2:237/33:49$= 33:50/33:51= 33:50/33:52= 48:2/39:13 34:47/42:23 42:43/42:39-42 23:96,41:34/42:42 33:47,48:2,48:5/46:9 8:57/47:4X 9:60,47:37/47:36$ 47:38/47:36-37$ 9:60/51:19,70:24-25$ 9:103/51:19$ 51:55/51:54 Regular prayers/52:48 52:21/53:39 56:39-40/56:13-14 60:9/60:8X 8:41,9:1/60:11=$X 54:46/67:16 76:30,81:29/73:19,76:29,80:12,81:28 87:6/75:16 9:73/88:22 94:7
Unsubstantiated: 2:104 2:150/2:115 2:130/2:158 17:33/2:178 2:194/2:190 2:222/2:187= 2:193/2:191X 17:33/2:194 9:103/2:219$ Narration/2:229= 4:12/2:240$= 9:73/2:256X Hadeeth/2:284 9:29/3:159X Sunna/4:19$= 9:17/5:2 Sunna/5:6 9:29/5:13X 9:36/6:66-67X 87:6/12:109 Sunna/12:109 16:18/14:34 22:28 23:96 Sunna/24:2= 24:58 Hadeeth/31:14 Sunna/33:4-5 Analysis/38:44 22:39/39:3X 39:53 40:77/40:77 Sunna/60:11=$X Consensus/60:12= 9:60/63:10$ Consensus/65:2= Regular prayers/73:1-4 20:2/73:4 4:28/73:5 17:79/76:26 9:60/87:14$ 107:7
|