For: The majority, including Ibn Abbaas, Ibn Umar, Sa`eed ibn Jabeer and Al-Hasan (in one report), Al-Husayn, Ash-Sha`bi, An-Nakh`i, Ad-Dhahhaak, Taawoos, Al-`Alaa' ibn Zayd, Muslim ibn Yasaar, Ibn Hazm Al-Andalusi, Ibn Abi-Najee`, Ibn Al-`Aaliya (according to Dr. Abdullah Al-Husayni), Mujaahid and `Ataa' (who opined for a partial abrogation), Ibn Shihaab (Az-Zuhri?), Zayd ibn Aslam (according to Makki), Ikrima (quoted by Ibn Salaam), Qataada, Ar-Rabee`, Iyaas ibn Mu`aawiya, Shurayh, As-Suddi, Naafi` (according to At-Tabari, wrote Dr. Zayd), Yahya ibn Al-Husayn ibn Al-Qaasim aka Al-Haadi, Abdullah ibn Al-Husayn and Al-Manssor Billah (according to Aş-Şa`di Al-Yamaani), Maalik, Al-Qaasim ibn Salaam, Makki, Ibn Al`Arabi (implied by one report), Abu-Bakr Al-Hamdaani, Abu-Ash-Shaykh Al-Haafizh (quoted by Al-Hamdaani), Ar-Raazi (implied by one report), Ibn Salaama, As-Suyooti, An-Nahhaas (in one report), Az-Zurqaani, Shah Waliullah Dehlvi, Ali Hasan Al-Areedh, Ash-Sha`raawi, Abdul-Qaahir Al-Baghdaadi and Dr. Hilmi Abdul-Haadi (according to Haani Taahir). Dr. Mannaa` Al-Qattaan (implied).
Against: Ibn Abbaas (in another report), Sa`eed ibn Jabeer (in another report according to Ibn Katheer), Qataada and Ar-Rabee` ibn Anas (in another report), Muqaatil ibn Hayyaan, Ash-Sha`bi, An-Nakh`i (another report), Al-Hasan Al-Basri, Taawoos, Ad-Dhahhaak (in another report), Masrooq, Muslim ibn Yasaar, Al-Alaa' ibn Yazeed, (in another report), Jaabir ibn Zayd, Abdul-Malik ibn Ya`la, Abul-`Aaliya, Ash-Sha`bi, Abdul-Malik ibn Amr and Laahiq ibn Hameed (according to At-Tabari, wrote Dr. Zayd), Abu-Bakr ibn Al`Arabi (in another report), At-Tabari, Ibn Al-Jawzi, Abu-Muslim Al-Asfahaani, Ar-Raazi (in another report by Al-Ghaali, page 68, quoting Ar-Raazi's exegesis volume 5 page 53), An-Nahhaas (in another report by Dr. Az-Zalmi, page 124), At-Tabari, Ibn Hazm Azh-Zhaahiri (quoted by Al-Jabri and Haani Taahir), Al-Qurtubi, Basheer-ud-Deen Mahmood (quoted by Al-Jabri and Haani Taahir), Al-Aloosi, As-Saawi (according to Dr. Az-Zalmi), Muhammad Abduh and M. Rasheed Ridha, Muhammad Al-Khudhari (Bek), Mustafa Khafaaji (in his book صفوف الكلام في أصول الأحكام, page 124, quoted by Al-Jabri), Al-Jabri, Ibn Al-Jaarood (implied, quoted by Al-Jabri), Abun-Nasr (implied by his narration that Al-Hasan, Taawoos and others said 2:180 was not abrogated), Dr. Mustafa Zayd, Dr. Ahmad Hijaazi As-Saqqa, M. M. Nada, Dr. Az-Zalmi, Dr. Muhammad Saalih Ali Mustafa, Husaam Al-Ghaali, Ihab Hasan Abduh, Dr. Ali Jum`a, Haani Taahir, Jamaal `Ataaya, Professor Ali Hasaballah (implied).
Unclear: Abu-Abdillah Shu`la (appears leaning toward abrogation).
_________________ A candle loses nothing by lighting another candle.
|