For: Ibn Abbaas, Al-Hasan (in one report, per Ash-Shawkaani), Ibn Al-Hanafiyya (Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Abi-Taalib) (according to Ash-Shawkaani), Sa`eed ibn Jabeer, Ikrima, Ad-Dhahhaak (according to Al-Khazraji), Ibn Jareer At-Tabari (who said 6:141 specifies the time of the Zakah on crops, according by Dr. Zayd), Ash-Shawkaani, `Atiyya, As-Suddi, Ibrahim An-Nakh`i (according to Dr. Zayd), Muhammad ibn Ja`far, `Ataa' ibn Abi-Rabaah, Hammaad, Mujaahid, Abdullah ibn Umar, Yazeed ibn Al-Asamm, Maymoon, Ar-Rabee` ibn Anas and Muhamamd ibn Ka`b (according to At-Tabari, says Dr. Zayd), An-Nahhaas.
Against: Ibn Abbaas (who said the right in 6:141 is the Zakah, according to Dr. Zayd and Shu`la), Ibn `Umar, Al-Hasan, Mujaahid and Ibn Abbaas (in other reports, per Al-Qaasim ibn Salaam and Ibn Al-Jawzi), Anas ibn Maalik, Sa`eed in Jabeer (according to Ibn Al-Jawzi), Taawoos, Ibrahim An-Nakh`i, Ash-Sha`bi (implied), Jaabir ibn Zayd, Sa`eed ibn Al-Musayyib, `Ataa' (according to Ibn Al-Jawzi and Makki), Qataada, Zayd ibn Aslam, Abu-`Ubayd Al-Qaasim ibn Salaam, Abul-`Aaliya, Abu-Haneefa, Maalik (according to Ibn Al`Arabi in his book أحكام القرآن, page 752, quoted by Dr. Zayd, also said by Makki, according to Dr. Faaris), Ash-Shaafi`i (implied, according to Al-Jabri. Dr. Faaris quoted Makki saying it was one of two opinions), Ja`far Aş-Şaadiq and Sufyaan (according to Shu`la), Ali ibn Al-Hasan, Ar-Rabee`, Muhammad ibn Al-Hanafiyya and Hammaad (according to Al-Jabri), Makki, Ibn Al-Jawzi, Az-Zamakhshari, Abu-Abdillah Shu`la, An-Nasfi, As-Zurqaani, Judge Ibn Al`Arabi, Al-Asfahaani, Ar-Raazi, Al-Jassaas, Ibn Katheer (implied), As-Suyooti, M. Rasheed Ridha (implied), Al-Jabri, Dr. Mustafa Zayd, Husaam Al-Ghaali, Ihab Hasan Abduh, Dr. M. Ibrahim Faaris (implied).
_________________ A candle loses nothing by lighting another candle.
|